Silence Official Review

silence3

  • Title: 深情密碼 / Shen Qing Mi Ma
  • English title: Silence
  • Genre: Romance
  • Episodes: 19
  • Broadcast network: CTV
  • Broadcast period: 2006 May 21 – 2006-Sep-24
  • Opening theme song: Jing Jing De (靜靜的) Silently by Harlem Yu
  • Ending theme song: Shou Xi De Wen Rou (熟悉的溫柔) Familiar gentleness by Vic Zhou

Cast

Dramaworld rating: 4.5/5

Dramaworld Spoiler Review(upcoming)

Synopsis

Zhou Shen Shen has a bus accident one day while riding with her friend Zuo Jun, and loses her voice as a result.  (who blames himself for making her mute) There she meets Qi Wei Yi , a boy who leg got broken by jealous peers. He finds a letter she had put in a bomb shelter wall. They  leave each other letters and  become good friends, but Wei Yi is unaware that Shen Shen is mute. When he has to leave before her, he gives her his phone number and tells her to call him. They promise to meet again in the Christmas of 2006. Years pass…Wei Yi has become a cold and distant company manager, while Shen Shen is a warm-hearted food seller. One day, they meet again – but each is unaware of who the other is…

Silence is unusual for Taiwan on several levels:  it borrows from Korean dramas by beginning with the lead characters as children, it innovatively used actors from three different Asian countries: Vic Zhou (Taiwan), Park Eun-hye (South Korea), and Andy Hui (Hong Kong), and  it was, unlike many Taiwanese dramas,  in general much more clearly a drama as opposed to a comedy. One of the main differences between Taiwanese and Korean dramas tend to be that Korean are much more angsty and tragic, even with their comedies, while Taiwanese lean toward more light-hearted with a good dose of angst and tragedy. Silence attempted to find a balance somewhere between these(it is, as someone once said, not as heartbreaking as some Korean dramas but is deeper than many fluffy Taiwanese dramas) .

Silence is an uneven drama, at times superb and at times overdrawn and melodramatic. Its two biggest flaws I would say are that it’s too long(as most dramas are) and that it relies too much on flashbacks/uses too much of the childhood story to bolster up the adult story, at the cost of time that could be spent expanding the plot or adding nuance to the current romance. That’s not to say, however, that it falls into the trap many childhood-loves-meet-again stories do, that of the two characters immediately falling in love again based on their memories and not on who they are as adults(Slumdog Millionaire is a good example of this), which always results in an unsatisfying and unconvincing romance. No, the drama succesfully portrays them as two adults who, meeting again, genuiniely fall in love with each other on their own terms and get to know each other again. But there are still far too many flashbacks to the childhood story and many of the most important scenes are awkwardly situated so as to fit back in the realm of that story, instead of giving the romance freedom to develop outside that story. It is also too long, in that the pace is too slow, it’s slightly repetitive(again, as with all dramas) and it extends or add things which are completely unnecessary. As with virtually all dramas, were Silence cut by one-third, it would be an immeasurably better drama.

However, the difference with Silence is that, were it to be cut, and even without it being cut, that other two-thirds of the drama are amazing beyond reason. Silence is in some ways a quiet drama, but in some ways it is also a very loud drama. It’s hard to pin down any one brilliant moment or scene for a large portion of it(though there are some) but rather it builds and builds on itself, steadily, subtly building up emotional and romantic tension, until almost without realizing it the viewer is completely sucked in – until finally, by the end, it is a deeply felt, incredible, deeply beautiful drama. I rarely cry over films or dramas, but I did over this one. It’s a highly unusual, incredibly beautiful work, with great performances from all the main leads and somehow a delicate, magical touch about it that(aside from its emotional seriousness/depth) makes it stand out from almost all other Taiwanese dramas I’ve seen. I was not particularly drawn by Silence the first few episodes. But give it time and it will assert itself. Highly recommended.

Watch at Mysoju

Download at Silent Regrets(you may have to register for access)

3 Responses

  1. I really disliked Andy Hui in the drama. I felt he was too overbearing and much too stubborn, constantly pushing himself onto Shen Shen. It ruined the drama.

  2. i like the story of silence. At first, I only watched it because Viz Zhou is in it but after a few episodes, i did not notice that i was already drawn in the story…I’m not the cry type person but this drama made me feel more human. It has some depths in it. It portrays a good attitude not only to plain romance but in almost all aspects of life itself, family, friendship, work relations, etc.. It shows different types of emotions and good virtues, happiness and sadness, pains and sacrifice, loyalty and contentment, and in the end the feeling of acceptance and perpetual glory…It can inspire people to live life to the fullest and to never take for granted people who cares for us because life is mysteriously unknown..we never know what will happen until it’s there right before our very own eyes already…The story may be somewhat tragic but in the end, if you look at it as a whole picture, it actually has a happy ending..the lead roles where able to spend happily together until one has to leave…sad but that is reality..life has to end…at least he died prepared and happy in the arms of his beloved..no regrets =)

  3. I just finished watching this great drama. This drama was EXTRAORDINARY! It’s very inspiring as well as romantic. Vic Zhou looks very handsome in this drama. Hehe. Watch it and you’ll have the best time!😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: